Telecom tribunal TDSAT on Tueasday gave a split verdict on validity of mobile phone operators offering 3G services beyond their licence areas through roaming pacts with its Chairman concurring with such a practice, while the other member on the bench differed with him.

The split verdict came on a petition filed by mobile phone companies challenging a government order asking them to stop offering 3G services beyond their licensed circles or zones through mutual roaming agreements.

The two-member bench comprising TDSAT Chairman Justice S B Sinha and Member P K Rastogi differed in theirs findings.

Justice Sinha allowed the telecom operators' plea against the government's directive to stop intra circle 3G roaming saying that it was violative of natural justice.

But Rastogi dismissed telecom operators plea saying they cannot provide roaming.

The operators would now appeal in higher courts.